Johnny’s Toys Castle Key and Birthday Card

A nostalgic nod to the legendary Johnny’s Toys birthday experience—only this time, there’s something a little off behind the door. Slime drips from the top. An eyeball stares through the keyhole. And a lone tentacle reaches out from underneath, curious... or hungry.

This card features a real metal key attached to the front, just like the ones kids once received to unlock birthday magic. But in true PopWater fashion, what waits behind the door might not be a toy—it might be watching.

Blank inside for your own message, warning, or birthday dare.

Greeting Card Details

• Size: 6.25” x 4.5”
• A real metal key attached to the front!
• Blank Inside
  
• Envelope included
• Paper weight: 60lb matte heavyweight cardstock